Tuesdays With Dorie: Irish Soda Bread

Irish soda Bread

This week’s TWD recipe is Irish Soda Bread, in celebration of Saint Patrick’s Day this past weekend (did you do anything fun?).

The bread gets its name from its use of, well what else, baking soda. As a researcher by day, I like to learn about the origin of different types of foods and how they evolved over time. According to this article, baking in Ireland has been influenced by two main factors. The first one being the Irish climate, which is much more temperate than other European countries and thus prevented hard wheats from growing properly. Hard wheats have high gluten content and are thus suitable for being raised with yeast. Soft wheats on the other hand do grow well in Ireland but contain less gluten than hard wheats (American all-purpose flour is a blend of hard and soft wheats). The second factor was the abundance of fuel such as firewood. This meant that every household could bake at home instead of using a communal oven.

These two factors contributed to the Irish baker using baking soda, or ‘bread soda’ in Ireland, as the main leavening agent. And traditionally this soda bread was baked in a pot (called a bastible) over the fire rather than in an oven. I also learned from this interesting interview with Irish chef Rory O’Connell that Irish soda bread in America is quite different from the one you can find in Ireland as the addition of butter and eggs, which is common in the U.S., would raise eyebrows over there.

I really enjoyed making this bread. The recipe was exceedingly simple, as it only required 4 ingredients (flour, salt, buttermilk and baking soda) and no kneading time. You can really make the dough in 10 minutes, then pop it into the oven for about 50 minutes and end up with a beautiful loaf of bread.

Dave and I bought buttermilk from our local Amish market (located a mere 5 minutes away from our apartment) and made several versions of the bread. I’ll have to admit that we did not stick to the traditional Irish way. Dave saw some chocolate yogurt covered raisins in the supermarket and got so excited about using them that I couldn’t resist, oh boy.

The bread turned out great (pictured above), a nice crust and a very dense crumb*, not at all dry, that’s good for spreads and dipping. Initially I thought that it tasted a wee bit too salty but then realized that maybe it’s meant to be eaten like a scone or biscuit? We gave half the loaf away to a friend who texted us the next day to let us know that her friend’s 17-month-old baby loved it. Always makes you happy when others appreciate your baking (and what good taste this baby has, really).

Since I had buttermilk left, I decided to make another loaf the next day. Dave had been badgering me about creating an ‘Asian’ version. So I give to you: the first-ever Dried Shrimp and Scallion Soda Bread. 

Dried shrimp and scallion soda bread

Obviously, I’m not calling this bread ‘Irish’ anymore – wonder what Chef O’Connell would think.  Dave came up with the combo, and I must say it was a pretty good idea. I only baked a small loaf (about the quarter the size of the previous one) because I didn’t have a lot of dried shrimp left at home. We ate it for breakfast alongside fried eggs drizzled with soy sauce.

*So in French, we have a word for crust (‘croute’) and we also have a word for the inside of the bread (‘mie’). When I put ‘mie’ in my online dictionary, here’s what it gives me: “bread without the crusts” and “soft interior of bread”. Huh?

Irish Soda Bread

This was baked as part of the TWD series, so for the basic 4-ingredient recipe head on to:

Carla of Chocolate Moosey or Cathleen of My Culinary Mission

For the sweet version shown in the first picture, here’s what we added to the base recipe:

  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 1/4-1/3 cup chocolate covered raisins
And for the ‘Asian’ version, add to the base recipe (proportions approximate because I was making a very small loaf):
  • 1/8 cup sugar
  • 1/4-1/3 cup dried shrimp, cut up in small pieces
  • 1/3 cup chopped scallions

Yvonne’s Corner

  • When you’ve mixed all the ingredients, the dough will be quite wet and very soft. This is normal so do not fret.
  • Do not overknead the dough.
  • Cutting the cross on the dough right before baking keeps the crust from cracking.
  • The recipe says that the bread will turn rock hard by the end of the day but I, and many other people, have not found it to be the case. Just wrap it tightly (I put mine in a big ziploc) and it will still be good the next day.
  • I greased my baking sheet with olive oil the first day, and canola oil the second day (it’s just less messy than butter). My second loaf had  a slightly nutty fragrance, which was great, that was almost reminiscent of you tiao and I wonder if it’s because of the canola oil.
  • Watch this short video of Julia Child baking Irish soda bread with Marion Cunningham and you’ll see how easy it is!

29 thoughts on “Tuesdays With Dorie: Irish Soda Bread

  1. Wow, an Asian version is soooo creative! The history of the bread is very interesting too. I pretty much kept to the recipe but you’ve inspired me to start thinking even more out of the box with this one.

    • Hi! I just saw the side by side comparison of the BWJ recipe and your recipe on your blog and also watched the video. Interesting that the kneading is so different in the two recipes. Do you think it makes a big difference?

      • The version my mother makes has egg in it and some baking powder, in addition to the basic ingredients. I think that’s what makes the longer kneading time necessary. It’s worth it, though!

      • Unfortunately, I can’t. It’s a recipe from a friend of my mother’s and she gave it to her on condition that she didn’t share it (though she was allowed to teach it to us, thank goodness).

  2. Loved the history write up. Okay, chocolate covered raisins…that is over the top! What a great idea! And loved that you made it “asian” – makes me want to make a peruvian version to highlight some of the great flavors here. yum!

  3. I love your Asian variation! Unfortunately we’re a no shrimp household because of my husband’s allergy but I eat bucketloads of it whenever my dad and I get together because we both love it so much. Scallions are one of my very favorite things to add to just about anything too. Sadly my variation did not work out as well as yours. Oh well. Recipes for April look fun!

    • I’m so glad that I don’t have any seafood allergies (or any food allergies for that matter) since I love seafood too! Sorry to hear your variation didn’t turn out as well but your challah looked fabulous (I actually added the sugar to the Asian variation because I liked that sweetness so much in the first loaf I made, and a lot of Asian breads tend to be ever so slightly sweet). And yes, recipes for April do look really fun. Looking forward to seeing how everybody’s turn out :)

  4. What great variations! I love chocolate covered raisins, that sounds excellent….The bread seemed kind of salty to me, too. Glad to know I’m not the only one.

  5. I’m so glad that Yvonne found such a great community to share her baking talents. I am extremely fortunate that she puts up with my requests as much as she does :-) Personally, I can’t wait until the next assignment with Dorie!

  6. Your loaves look delicious! How fun to try all different versions. I thought this bread was reminiscent of a biscuit too and I loved how easy it was!

Would love some feedback!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s